Scores reflect the Overall AI Score for each category
Based on recent customer reviews, BMW South Africa is judged far more on what happens after the sale than on the product itself. Customers consistently describe unresolved faults, parts held on back order without timelines, and complaints escalated to head office that go unanswered. A recurring theme is that individual consultants earn genuine praise while the wider brand response feels absent.
Top Strengths:
- •Staff Professionalism & Conduct: Where staff are named, the praise is emphatic. Tshiwela at Mini Northcliff, Lindo Skosana at JHB South, Dylan at Fourways and Derek Kleintjes with Aviwe Mncwabe at Menlyn are described as knowledgeable, patient and genuinely invested in customers.
TrustIndex
2.3
NPS Score
-78
Recommended: Unlikely
Dec '25 - Nov '26
Frequently Asked Questions About BMW South Africa
What do customers say about BMW South Africa?
Based on recent customer reviews, BMW South Africa is judged far more on what happens after the sale than on the product itself. Customers consistently describe unresolved faults, parts held on back order without timelines, and complaints escalated to head office that go unanswered. A recurring theme is that individual consultants earn genuine praise while the wider brand response feels absent.
What is BMW South Africa's biggest strength?
BMW South Africa's biggest strength, according to Hellopeter's AI analysis, is Staff Professionalism & Conduct. Where staff are named, the praise is emphatic. Tshiwela at Mini Northcliff, Lindo Skosana at JHB South, Dylan at Fourways and Derek Kleintjes with Aviwe Mncwabe at Menlyn are described as knowledgeable, patient and genuinely invested in customers.
What are the most common complaints about BMW South Africa?
The most common complaint about BMW South Africa, based on Hellopeter's AI analysis of recent customer reviews, is Communication & Aftercare. Customers repeatedly describe being ghosted after logging complaints with BMW South Africa, promised callbacks that never come, and being passed between dealership, head office and third party administrators with nobody accepting ownership of the outcome.
How does BMW South Africa compare to other Car Brands companies?
BMW South Africa scores 1.1 out of 5 on Hellopeter's AI analysis of service quality in Car Brands, compared to the Car Brands industry average of 1. Their strongest theme is Sales & Handover (1.7); their weakest is Reliability & Warranty (0.9). The top AI-rated Car Brands business on Hellopeter is (). How is the AI Score calculated? →
Is BMW South Africa trustworthy?
BMW South Africa has a TrustIndex of 2.3 out of 10 on Hellopeter, based on 52 reviews in the last 12 months. Hellopeter has tracked BMW South Africa across 1,318 total reviews. How is the TrustIndex calculated? →
Recent reviews (52)
Used this business recently? Share your experience to help others decide.
Used this business recently? Share your experience to help others decide.
Share Your Experience1 reviews | Active since Sept 2019
Horrifically bad.
I tried getting hold of parts dept at Bmw Clearwater 19/10/2026. I was advised by their call center no-one was available as they were all on lunch. I left amessage to be called back, this never happened. I called back the next morning, i could not get hold of the manager of parts or the dealer principal. I contact BMW SA to complain about the appalling service. The lady there was very apologetic and promised she will get to the bottom of this, lo and behold i have not heard a peep from from them. IS THE GERMAN ENGINEERING WHEN YOU NEED IT MOST. When you drive a Bmw with the price tag it has, this is the last thing you expect. Ridiculous, i can now understand why there are such a lot of Chinese cars on our roads.
1 reviews | Active since Sept 2019
Horrifically bad.
I tried getting hold of parts dept at Bmw Clearwater 19/10/2026. I was advised by their call center no-one was available as they were all on lunch. I left amessage to be called back, this never happened. I called back the next morning, i could not get hold of the manager of parts or the dealer principal. I contact BMW SA to complain about the appalling service. The lady there was very apologetic and promised she will get to the bottom of this, lo and behold i have not heard a peep from from them. IS THE GERMAN ENGINEERING WHEN YOU NEED IT MOST. When you drive a Bmw with the price tag it has, this is the last thing you expect. Ridiculous, i can now understand why there are such a lot of Chinese cars on our roads.
1 reviews | Active since Sept 2026
Debt
I have one of your employers,from Rosslyn plant who is owing me money and shes been giving me excuses for the period of 5 days now.How can HR assist in this regard
1 reviews | Active since Sept 2026
Debt
I have one of your employers,from Rosslyn plant who is owing me money and shes been giving me excuses for the period of 5 days now.How can HR assist in this regard
1 reviews | Active since Nov 2023
Formal Complaint Follow-Up - ***
The customer service response has been frustrating and unhelpful. Instead of addressing my formal complaint regarding unnecessary service frequency, lack of service bundling, and an out-of-pocket overcharge for a prematurely replaced microfilter, the team simply forwarded internal job cards back to me without any explanation or resolution. Passing along raw documents without engaging with the clear evidence of premature billing on my invoices shows a total lack of accountability and efficiency. I expect Head Office to actually investigate the overcharge and address the fragmented service practices rather than sending copy-paste automated replies.
1 reviews | Active since Nov 2023
Formal Complaint Follow-Up - ***
The customer service response has been frustrating and unhelpful. Instead of addressing my formal complaint regarding unnecessary service frequency, lack of service bundling, and an out-of-pocket overcharge for a prematurely replaced microfilter, the team simply forwarded internal job cards back to me without any explanation or resolution. Passing along raw documents without engaging with the clear evidence of premature billing on my invoices shows a total lack of accountability and efficiency. I expect Head Office to actually investigate the overcharge and address the fragmented service practices rather than sending copy-paste automated replies.
1 reviews | Active since Jan 2017
BMW POLOKWANE
USED TO LOVE THIS CAR BUT AFTER THE SERVICE I RECEIVED IN POLOKWANE SERVICE DEPARTMENT IM MOVING TO ANOTHER BRAND AS SOON AS MY CAR IS PAID UP THEY MADE ME BUY VEHICLE PARTS TO TAKE TO A CERTIFIED PANELBEATER WHO REFUSED TO TAKE THE BMW PARTS AND INSISTED THAT I BUY THEIRS. TOOK THE PARTS BACK TO BMW FOR A REFUND THEY TOLD ME I SHOULD NOT HAVE BOUGHT PARTS FROM THEM AND I SHOULD ESCALATE WITH THEIR CALL CENTRE, RAN AROUND WITH THE PARTS FOR 3 MONTHS NOT KNOWING WHAT TO DO WITH THEM
1 reviews | Active since Jan 2017
BMW POLOKWANE
USED TO LOVE THIS CAR BUT AFTER THE SERVICE I RECEIVED IN POLOKWANE SERVICE DEPARTMENT IM MOVING TO ANOTHER BRAND AS SOON AS MY CAR IS PAID UP THEY MADE ME BUY VEHICLE PARTS TO TAKE TO A CERTIFIED PANELBEATER WHO REFUSED TO TAKE THE BMW PARTS AND INSISTED THAT I BUY THEIRS. TOOK THE PARTS BACK TO BMW FOR A REFUND THEY TOLD ME I SHOULD NOT HAVE BOUGHT PARTS FROM THEM AND I SHOULD ESCALATE WITH THEIR CALL CENTRE, RAN AROUND WITH THE PARTS FOR 3 MONTHS NOT KNOWING WHAT TO DO WITH THEM
1 reviews | Active since Aug 2026
Why pay for fault finding if the fault is obvious and visible?!
I went to a dealership for a service for my Company Car (116i) and had 2 issues I needed looking at: Irregular Idling Aircon not working - I paid to have the aircon fixed around 6 months earlier. The service advisor mentioned the R1700 fault finding for each, which I then said that I will first speak to my boss about it. The standard service and rear brake pads was done (R13000). When collecting the car, the service advisor said she can point out the problems on both, which I have to say, is something a person with a LITTLE car experience would have picked up straight away. When opening the bonnet, one could see the one air pipe being broken, and on the one pipe one could see where the coolant leaked. I am not that way inclined, so would not even have seen either. Now the real complaint. Considering that for the trained eye, these probably took 10 seconds to diagnose, I asked the advisor if I can bring the car back to have those 2 issues sorted, to which she replies that they will still have to charge the R1700 fault finding fee for each. I then said that "it is not needed because the faults are identified", and as mentioned, "probably took the trained eye 10 seconds, why do I still have to pay the R3400". To which she answered: "That is how BMW works, and we have to report it to them". My response was something like... "This is not a warranty issue where BMW pays, I pay, so no need to report it to BMW", she then just said: "That is just how it works". The nett effect here, is that it just feels to me that because I love my BMW, and BMW knows that to be true, because they also love theirs, as if BMW will just ride on that fact and because we love our BMW's as much as we do, that we will just pay, and pay. Well, I am not sure I agree... I will pay what is due and fair is fair, but don't open an umbrella.........
1 reviews | Active since Aug 2026
Why pay for fault finding if the fault is obvious and visible?!
I went to a dealership for a service for my Company Car (116i) and had 2 issues I needed looking at: Irregular Idling Aircon not working - I paid to have the aircon fixed around 6 months earlier. The service advisor mentioned the R1700 fault finding for each, which I then said that I will first speak to my boss about it. The standard service and rear brake pads was done (R13000). When collecting the car, the service advisor said she can point out the problems on both, which I have to say, is something a person with a LITTLE car experience would have picked up straight away. When opening the bonnet, one could see the one air pipe being broken, and on the one pipe one could see where the coolant leaked. I am not that way inclined, so would not even have seen either. Now the real complaint. Considering that for the trained eye, these probably took 10 seconds to diagnose, I asked the advisor if I can bring the car back to have those 2 issues sorted, to which she replies that they will still have to charge the R1700 fault finding fee for each. I then said that "it is not needed because the faults are identified", and as mentioned, "probably took the trained eye 10 seconds, why do I still have to pay the R3400". To which she answered: "That is how BMW works, and we have to report it to them". My response was something like... "This is not a warranty issue where BMW pays, I pay, so no need to report it to BMW", she then just said: "That is just how it works". The nett effect here, is that it just feels to me that because I love my BMW, and BMW knows that to be true, because they also love theirs, as if BMW will just ride on that fact and because we love our BMW's as much as we do, that we will just pay, and pay. Well, I am not sure I agree... I will pay what is due and fair is fair, but don't open an umbrella.........
1 reviews | Active since Apr 2024
************** by sales representatives BMW Kempton Park (Nosi) and sales manager (Wesley)
When I purchased my vehicle, BMW Kempton Park intentionally provided it with old tyres. When I brought this to your attention, Head Office refused to resolve the issue or provide new tyres. To make matters worse, I am now being forced to chase BMW Kempton Park simply to get my vehicle registration papers. The service from my sales representative, Nosi, has been entirely unprofessional. Every time I follow up on my papers, she reacts with anger. She routinely "blue-ticks" my text messages, intentionally ignoring my queries for hours before offering a delayed response. Instead of receiving proactive communication and feedback, the burden has been placed entirely on me to follow up constantly. Given the combination of poor vehicle preparation, a refusal to rectify the tyre safety issue, and the ongoing struggle to get my documents, I am deeply disappointed to be treated like this as a Black customer. A premium brand should offer equitable, professional service to everyone, yet I feel targeted and completely disregarded.
1 reviews | Active since Apr 2024
************** by sales representatives BMW Kempton Park (Nosi) and sales manager (Wesley)
When I purchased my vehicle, BMW Kempton Park intentionally provided it with old tyres. When I brought this to your attention, Head Office refused to resolve the issue or provide new tyres. To make matters worse, I am now being forced to chase BMW Kempton Park simply to get my vehicle registration papers. The service from my sales representative, Nosi, has been entirely unprofessional. Every time I follow up on my papers, she reacts with anger. She routinely "blue-ticks" my text messages, intentionally ignoring my queries for hours before offering a delayed response. Instead of receiving proactive communication and feedback, the burden has been placed entirely on me to follow up constantly. Given the combination of poor vehicle preparation, a refusal to rectify the tyre safety issue, and the ongoing struggle to get my documents, I am deeply disappointed to be treated like this as a Black customer. A premium brand should offer equitable, professional service to everyone, yet I feel targeted and completely disregarded.
1 reviews | Active since Dec 2020
BMW South Africa – Extremely Poor Customer Service
I am extremely disappointed with BMW South Africa and the way my complaint has been handled. A BMW dealership supp**** me with the incorrect part, and instead of taking responsibility and resolving an error made on their side, I have been passed around and given excuses. I have now been without my vehicle for two full days because of this. What makes this even more frustrating is that I have followed the proper channels and still cannot get someone to take ownership of the situation. For a brand that markets itself as premium, this level of customer service is completely unacceptable. I am now escalating this matter further because apparently the normal BMW channels are incapable of resolving a straightforward customer complaint. BMW South Africa needs to take accountability and resolve this matter.
1 reviews | Active since Dec 2020
BMW South Africa – Extremely Poor Customer Service
I am extremely disappointed with BMW South Africa and the way my complaint has been handled. A BMW dealership supp**** me with the incorrect part, and instead of taking responsibility and resolving an error made on their side, I have been passed around and given excuses. I have now been without my vehicle for two full days because of this. What makes this even more frustrating is that I have followed the proper channels and still cannot get someone to take ownership of the situation. For a brand that markets itself as premium, this level of customer service is completely unacceptable. I am now escalating this matter further because apparently the normal BMW channels are incapable of resolving a straightforward customer complaint. BMW South Africa needs to take accountability and resolve this matter.
1 reviews | Active since Aug 2026
BMW'S Unavailability of Parts with NO lead time.
I am highly disappointed with the service I am receiving from BMW South Africa after my vehicle has been stuck in a BMW workshop for a month due to parts unavailability. I specifically chose to purchase a BMWs for the past decade because of its reliability of the brand being the main factor and its heart breaking to be going through so much frustration and dissatisfaction at this point. I am writing this email simply because the parts that I am waiting for still doesn’t have an ETA from order date 22nd July 2026 to date. 5 weeks later and who knows how much longer still nothing while i struggle the get around. On the online page there's a misrepresentation that states that customer service is available on weekends Saturday 08:00 - 13:00 and to my disappointment there no one available to talk to during the said times as per web page. The service breakdown at this point is unbelievable from such a reputable brand. Loyal dissatisfied customer Nolo
1 reviews | Active since Aug 2026
BMW'S Unavailability of Parts with NO lead time.
I am highly disappointed with the service I am receiving from BMW South Africa after my vehicle has been stuck in a BMW workshop for a month due to parts unavailability. I specifically chose to purchase a BMWs for the past decade because of its reliability of the brand being the main factor and its heart breaking to be going through so much frustration and dissatisfaction at this point. I am writing this email simply because the parts that I am waiting for still doesn’t have an ETA from order date 22nd July 2026 to date. 5 weeks later and who knows how much longer still nothing while i struggle the get around. On the online page there's a misrepresentation that states that customer service is available on weekends Saturday 08:00 - 13:00 and to my disappointment there no one available to talk to during the said times as per web page. The service breakdown at this point is unbelievable from such a reputable brand. Loyal dissatisfied customer Nolo