Steve Madden Logo

Steve Madden

Claimed Business
|1.5
45 Reviews (last 12 months)
Does not respond to reviews

Scores reflect the Overall AI Score for each category

AI Review Summary

Based on recent customer reviews, Steve Madden is drawing sustained criticism for its online ordering and returns operation. Shoppers describe long waits for refunds, partial PayJustNow reversals, missing or incorrect items, and emails and calls that go unanswered. Product durability is a recurring concern, with sneakers and heels peeling, cracking or tearing within weeks, and complaints often met with a six month policy response. Praise comes almost entirely from store level, where managers and staff at Vaal Mall, Mall of the South and Woodmead went out of their way to assist.

Service Quality Ratings
Industry Avg: 1.9Best: 4.8 (Progenix)
Industry Avg: 1.5Best: 4.7 (Eden Perfumes)
Industry Avg: 1.9Best: 4.7 (Faithful To Nature)
Industry Avg: 1Best: 4.3 (Miele (Pty) Ltd)
Industry Avg: 1.2Best: 3.1 (Shoebox Online)
Overall AI Score
1.2
Industry Avg: 1.6Best: 4.7 (Progenix)
4.5-5 Excellent
3.5-4.5 Great
2.5-3.5 Average
1.5-2.5 Poor
<1.5 Terrible
Performance(last 12 months):
Trustindex Rating
2.2
NPS Score
-88Unlikely
Review Distribution
1.5|45 Reviews

Dec '25 - Nov '26

Frequently Asked Questions About Steve Madden

What do customers say about Steve Madden?

Based on recent customer reviews, Steve Madden is drawing sustained criticism for its online ordering and returns operation. Shoppers describe long waits for refunds, partial PayJustNow reversals, missing or incorrect items, and emails and calls that go unanswered. Product durability is a recurring concern, with sneakers and heels peeling, cracking or tearing within weeks, and complaints often met with a six month policy response. Praise comes almost entirely from store level, where managers and staff at Vaal Mall, Mall of the South and Woodmead went out of their way to assist.

Is Steve Madden trustworthy?

Steve Madden has a TrustIndex of 2.2 out of 10 on Hellopeter, based on 45 reviews in the last 12 months. Hellopeter has tracked Steve Madden across 303 total reviews. How is the TrustIndex calculated? →

Recent reviews (45)

Used this business recently? Share your experience to help others decide.

Share Your Experience
MS
Miviwe S

1 reviews | Active since Nov 2026

18 Nov 2026, 20:43

Take long to deliver

Take so long to deliver. It does not communicate at all

0
Replies (0)
More
AS
Anita S

1 reviews | Active since Oct 2025

17 Nov 2026, 08:53

Pathetic treatment at Steve Madden!!

I recently bought Steve Madden's new jelly shoe sandal which has just been released, I wore the shoe one in fitting around the house because I bought my exact size which I wear, to my realization I noticed that actually the shoe is small because I purchased it online. I then went into the store to have it exchanged for 1 size up, when I got there, they advised that the show could not be exchanged because it is "damaged" when only worn once being fitted on, so how could it be damaged when I bought it 2 weeks ago? It means their products are defective because why would I buy a slide for R899.00 only for it to be "damaged" in just a week, worn in the house? I want my money because I feel discriminated against, we all know had it been a white person complaining they would have made sure to keep them satisfied. Please do not waste your money their products are defective and definitely not worth your hard-earned money.

0
Replies (0)
More
MM
Mpho M

1 reviews | Active since Sept 2023

3 Nov 2026, 11:43

Bad customer service ,********

I ordered a sneaker and t shirt on the 24th of October ,on the 27 i recived the t shirt and not my entire order,waited the whole week withought an update from Steve Madden and nothing then i called was told that the sneaker is out of stock i will recieve a refund ,till date nothing i am busy calling everyday and im being told the finance team has not attended the query the way they should have ,everytime you ask why there is no answer . Can i please get my money

0
Replies (0)
More
TM
Tshegofatso M

1 reviews | Active since Sept 2019

30 Oct 2026, 09:59

Defective wallet from Steve Madden Menlyn

I purchased wallet defective in July when I returned it store manager refused now I've been complaining to their head office they say they can't help me who must help me , they don't to exchange or refund me meaning I must just throw it away imagine throwing away 1000 in thise economy I am really disappointed and all my wallet I am buying there NO MORE

0
Replies (0)
More
LP
Lenardene P

1 reviews | Active since Aug 2024

29 Oct 2026, 14:08

Worst experience ever

I purchased a Steve madden tracksuit both was available, pants was delivered yesterday and they emailed me to say they going to refund me the tops money which is very unacceptable, the day I purchased the tracksuit both was available very very disappointed.

0
Replies (0)
More
MS
Martha S

1 reviews | Active since Mar 2021

24 Oct 2026, 17:13

Vaal Mall Manager is rude, unprofessional and very *********, refused to assist with refund and was very disrespectful towards me.

Vaal Mall manager is very *********, unprofessional, disrespectful and rude I bought a t shirt at Steve Madden East Point on friday the 16th of October 2026 but unfortunately it was not the right fit for the person I was buying for. In a few days I bought the right size online planning to take back the wrong size in store for a refund. I misplaced the Tax invoice but still have the payment slip. I went to Vaal Mall on the 23rd of October 2026 to return the t shirt and the manager was very rude claiming that the t shirt has been worn and washed, whilst the t shirt is still in the same condition I got it I when I bought it. She kept giving excuses saying is has lint, and that I washed it. I left there in disbelief because even the other employee didn't say anything he even looked scared to speak. That manager is a bully and has created even a hostile working environment, worse she even disrespects customers. I'm going to take this forward, I will not quit till I get my refund, if her pregnancy makes her smell soap on clothes she must get a second opinion but now the other employees seem scared to confront her.

0
Replies (0)
More
TK
Tabudi K

1 reviews | Active since Oct 2017

24 Oct 2026, 03:06

Extremely dissapointing experience : wrong item delivered and poor value cor money

I am extremely disappointed and dissatisfied with my experience with Steve Madden. I placed an online order for a specific bag, paid for the item I selected, and received a completely different bag from the one i odered , the bag delivered is of a lower price than the bag I actually purchased. I paid for a particular product and received something entirely different and cheaper. This is unacceptable and leaves me feeling completely ********** As a paying customer, I expect to receive the exact item I ordered, not an incorrect product that is worth less than what I paid for. Mistakes can happen, but the way this affects the customer should not be taken lightly. I should not have to waste my time chasing a company to correct an error that was not mine. I am extremely unhappy with this purchase, and my trust in the brand has been seriously affected.

0
Replies (0)
More
sM
sandisiwe M

1 reviews | Active since Jul 2024

28 Sept 2026, 22:26

Very disappointed

Good day, I ordered these shoes specifically for an upcoming event, but unfortunately I received the wrong size. I ordered a size 6.5, but I received a size 7.5 instead. I am extremely disappointed because I spent my last money on this order, expecting to receive exactly what I purchased. The shoes are unfortunately too big and look completely different on me because of the incorrect size. This has been a very frustrating and exhausting experience. Customers spend a lot of money trusting your brand, and I feel that more care should be taken when processing orders. I urgently need this issue resolved. Please arrange for the correct size (6.5) to be sent to me and advise me on the return process for the incorrect pair. I look forward to your urgent response and resolution.

0
Replies (0)
More