1 reviews | Active since Dec 2024
Diagnostic Inaccuracy, Severe Negligence, and Medication Errors at Milpark Hospital Emergency Dept
On 1 September 2026, I presented to the emergency department at Netcare Milpark Hospital at approximately 11:00 AM following a traumatic mugging and a subsequent car collision where my vehicle impacted my garage wall. I presented with acute, severe symptoms: difficulty breathing, chest tightness, pain and swelling in my upper body region, profound weakness, persistent vomiting from the night before, and severe pain inside my neck and throat.The hospital staff checked my vitals, took a blood sugar reading, and collected a urine sample. Prior to the doctor's arrival, the attending nurse conducted a preliminary interview and asked specific diagnostic questions regarding whether I was experiencing any bleeding. I informed the nurse that I had recently noticed blood when using the bathroom. The nurse explicitly asked if I was currently on my menstrual period, which I firmly denied, confirming the bleeding was anomalous.Despite presenting with active respiratory distress, trauma, and internal bleeding symptoms, my wait time exceeded five hours. I was only evaluated by the attending physician from Doctors Murugan and Swartzberg Inc at approximately 4:00 PM. I provided my pain severity rating as an 8 out of 10.The physician demonstrated gross clinical oversight. I never reported general cervical neck pain or muscle stiffness, yet she incorrectly recorded my diagnosis as "Torticollis, Cervical Region" (ICD-10 M43.62) to my medical aid. She then told me she would provide something for pain and to calm down. When I questioned her about treatment for my nausea and vomiting, she flatly denied that I had mentioned it. Only when I firmly corrected her did she review her memory and acknowledge that I had indeed informed her. Despite the high-impact collision and my upper body swelling, she performed no diagnostic chest scans or internal throat examinations.Furthermore, a critical pharmacological error occurred. The physician issued a duplicated prescription containing overlapping medications, specifically putting down a double order of Sinaleve alongside Voltaren pads. This dangerous medication error was only intercepted because the dispensing pharmacist identified the duplication and refused to fill it.When I immediately returned to the emergency room to confront the physician regarding the ignored symptoms and the duplicated medications, she responded with absolute nonchalance, asking me, "How can I help you be okay?" After I pointed out the duplication and demanded treatment matching my actual symptoms, she took the prescription back to update it. Her manner throughout was completely unbothered, nonchalant, and unwelcoming. I require an immediate, formal investigation by hospital administration into the extreme triage delays, the severe diagnostic miscoding, and the unsafe prescribing practices of this physician.
