Auto & General Logo

Auto & General

Verified Business
|4.6
7,617 Reviews (last 12 months)
Responds in 22m

Scores reflect the Overall AI Score for each category

AI Review Summary

Based on recent customer reviews, Auto & General presents a sharply divided customer experience. Named call centre consultants earn consistent praise for premium reviews, policy updates and cancellations, lifting Agent Quality (4.6) and Pricing, Premiums & Transparency (4.1). However, a recurring theme is that once a claim is lodged, particularly warranty, geyser or panel beater claims, communication collapses and Claims Handling (3.3) and Repair & Service Provider Quality (2.8) suffer badly.

Top Strengths:

  • •Agent Quality & Customer Care: Customers name individual consultants repeatedly, praising patience, product knowledge and warmth. Names such as Sashin Madurai, Anele Ndlovu, Clair Naidoo, Sebastian Ramouthar, Windy Mbobo and Mbali Khumalo recur with words like star, gem and above and beyond.
Service Quality Ratings
Industry Avg: 2.9Best: 4.3 (Bsure Insurance Advisors)
Industry Avg: 3Best: 4.5 (CLC)
Industry Avg: 4.1Best: 4.7 (Future Green Dot)
Industry Avg: 2.7Best: 4.3 (Future Green Dot)
Industry Avg: 2.9Best: 4.4 (CLC)
Overall AI Score
3.7
Industry Avg: 3.1Best: 4.4 (CLC)
4.5-5 Excellent
3.5-4.5 Great
2.5-3.5 Average
1.5-2.5 Poor
<1.5 Terrible
Performance(last 12 months):
Trustindex Rating
10
Ranked In Home Insurance
#11
Reply Time
22m
NPS Score
42Likely

Replied to 99% of negative reviews

Reply time on negative reviews: 40m

Review Distribution
4.6|7,617 Reviews

Dec '25 - Nov '26

Frequently Asked Questions About Auto & General

What do customers say about Auto & General?

Based on recent customer reviews, Auto & General presents a sharply divided customer experience. Named call centre consultants earn consistent praise for premium reviews, policy updates and cancellations, lifting Agent Quality (4.6) and Pricing, Premiums & Transparency (4.1). However, a recurring theme is that once a claim is lodged, particularly warranty, geyser or panel beater claims, communication collapses and Claims Handling (3.3) and Repair & Service Provider Quality (2.8) suffer badly.

What is Auto & General's biggest strength?

Auto & General's biggest strength, according to Hellopeter's AI analysis, is Agent Quality & Customer Care. Customers name individual consultants repeatedly, praising patience, product knowledge and warmth. Names such as Sashin Madurai, Anele Ndlovu, Clair Naidoo, Sebastian Ramouthar, Windy Mbobo and Mbali Khumalo recur with words like star, gem and above and beyond.

What are the most common complaints about Auto & General?

The most common complaint about Auto & General, based on Hellopeter's AI analysis of recent customer reviews, is Claims Handling & Resolution. Motor and windscreen claims often move quickly and payouts are praised. Warranty, VAP, geyser and household claims draw the harshest criticism, with partial approvals, technicality rejections, repeated document requests and weeks of silence from named handlers.

How does Auto & General compare to other Car Insurance companies?

Auto & General scores 3.2 out of 5 on Hellopeter's AI analysis of service quality in Car Insurance, compared to the Car Insurance industry average of 3.2. Their strongest theme is Agent Service (4.4); their weakest is Repair Quality (2.3). The top AI-rated Car Insurance business on Hellopeter is OUTsurance (4.2). How is the AI Score calculated? →

Is Auto & General trustworthy?

Auto & General has a TrustIndex of 10 out of 10 on Hellopeter, based on 7,617 reviews in the last 12 months. They reply to 99% of negative reviews, typically within 40 min. Hellopeter has tracked Auto & General across 30,234 total reviews. How is the TrustIndex calculated? →

Recent reviews (7,617)

Used this business recently? Share your experience to help others decide.

Share Your Experience
TM
Terreza M

1 reviews | Active since Nov 2024

21 Nov 2026, 17:30

Cancelled policy they still debited my money

I cancelled my policy but they still debited my money. If they know what's good for them they will refund my money ASAP

0
Replies (1)
More
UM
Usivhone M

1 reviews | Active since Sept 2018

21 Nov 2026, 08:18

Disappointed by Auto & General's Claims Practices – Read the Fine Print

BE WARNED about Auto & General's home contents insurance practices when it comes time to actually submit a claim. While I understand that some of these rules might be standard practice across the insurance industry, I unfortunately happened to fall victim to how this insurer applies them—and the lack of upfront transparency when taking out the policy. After suffering a break-in where high-value items were ******, I encountered several major issues during the claims process: 1. The "Under-insured" Trap: When you take out the policy, Auto & General does not properly advise or warn you about the risk of being under-insured, nor do they actively guide you on assessing your total household replacement value. Worse still, they don't count your declared/specified items amount toward the total value of your insurance when assessing whether your home contents are adequately covered. Then, the moment you submit a claim, they are quick to apply the "average formula" to penalize you and drastically reduce your payout. 2. Unfair Valuation Without Receipts: Like most everyday people, I did not keep physical receipts for every single item I own. Nowhere did they emphasize in advance that without original receipts, they will default to using minimal amounts to calculate replacement values—sometimes even pricing out far inferior, cheaper items to do their costing rather than replacing like-for-like. 3. Customer support/service takes forever during the claims process. There's no consideration whatsoever in terms of updating the customer where the process is. It feels as though the policy is designed to collect premiums easily, while the claims stage is structured to minimize payouts through technicalities that aren't highlighted upfront. If you are insured with Auto & General or considering them, I suggest you look for alternatives.

0
Replies (1)
More
SS
Sheillah S

1 reviews | Active since Jan 2024

20 Nov 2026, 21:25

INSURANCE NIGHTMARE. I AM SO DISAPPOINTED, BROKEN, OVERWHELMED, DRAINED!

FOUR MONTHS WITHOUT MY CAR — LIES, HIDDEN COSTS, AND ZERO ACCOUNTABILITY FROM AUTO & GENERAL I have been patient enough. I have lost so much. People warned me about Auto & General, and I honestly thought they were exaggerating. Now I am living the nightmare myself. Have you ever faithfully paid every single month for a product you are not even using? If you miss one debit order, Auto & General will chase you like nobody’s business. Yet when it is their turn to honor a valid claim, you have to spend thousands of Rands out of pocket just begging for an update. Here is the full, undeniable timeline of what they have put me through since 23 July 2026 (Claim Ref: 630....): • False Sales Promises & Hidden Out-of-Pocket Costs: When Auto & General sold me this Unlimited Cover policy, they boasted that they could even buy an engine straight from Ford. When my Ford Fiesta’s showed "engine oil low pressure with a 100% up-to-date service history), they initially towed it to Ford Randburg. Ford took 7 full days of me pushing them just to run a diagnostic with their machine and they found engine failure, and then quoted nearly R14K to strip the engine so Auto & General could see pictures. Auto & General refused to pay, saying they only cover R4,000 for diagnostics and stripping. Because I didn't have the extra R10,000, they told me to move the car to an RMI dealership. They asked me to look around since they had no preferred workshops and told me to move my car at my own expense to an RMI workshop of my choice! I had to pay out of pocket for a private tow truck to Car Service City Strijdom Park, AND pay Ford nearly R2,000 for diagnostics myself because Auto & General said they "only pay once per incident." • Contradictions & Moving Goalposts: Mid-claim, Auto & General suddenly wanted to move my car from Car Service City to their own workshop in Kempton Park—after previously telling me they didn't have any workshops! They claimed Car Service City's quote was "too expensive," yet when I asked what their limit was on an unlimited policy, they refused to disclose it. They eventually backed down on moving the car. • Trying to Cheat Me on Parts & Policy Terms: Next, they tried to force a cheap "sub-assembly" engine that the workshop confirmed would not work. When they finally agreed to a new engine, they tried to reject my turbocharger, claiming my policy didn't allow claiming for two things simultaneously! When I proved that clause wasn't in my contract, they actually sent me a revised policy trying to slip that indemnity in mid-claim! After fighting their dispute department for weeks, they finally called at the end of October admitting they had to cover both because I was never given that clause when I joined. • Walls of Silence & Unanswered Calls: Auto & General claims their assessors take a maximum of 3 days but mine took a minimum of 2 weeks after I called almost every single day. Whenever I tried to reach managers like Pertunia or Tumo, they were always "unavailable" or promised to call back but it was all empty dreams. Out of every 6 calls, maybe they returned 1 call. They refuse to put updates in writing and leave my countless emails unanswered, the only immediate email I ever got was when they tried to reject my turbocharger. • The Supplier Disaster (Tradefed): Car Service City wanted to use their own reliable supplier, but Auto & General insisted on buying the parts themselves. In October, said they paid Tradefed Parts Claims R.... for a brand-new OEM engine and turbocharger. Instead, Tradefed delivered a refurbished engine! Auto & General told the workshop not to touch it. I spent almost 2 weeks as they were busy solving their problems with Tradefed. I told them that they cant keep fighting while I am waiting for my car to be fixed. They will sort their dispute later not at my expense. I tried to do a follow up but nothing was solved.they later on said they have paid Tradefed a top up for a new engine. Asked them when the parts will be delivered. They said they didn't know. I asked them to call and they said they dont call claiming that they only communicate via emails and emails were not replied to. Since then, Auto & General refused to even phone Tradefed out of pure desperation, I called Tradefed (using the numbers I got from google) myself. 90% of the time they broke their promises to call back—promising delivery last Wednesday, then Tuesday this week, then Thursday, then Friday morning. Nothing arrived! When I followed up today, the person in charge shouted at me and told me I wasn't supposed to be speaking to him. He said I am invading his privacy since I am calling any time. I only call between 9 and 5. He also said that Auto and general should reach out. On the other hand, Auto and general said they were waiting for the response from the supplier. Friday is over, and nothing was delivered. • My Stripped Car & Storage Fee Threats: Right now, my car is sitting completely stripped and open in the workshop. I understand the dealership's frustration that bay could have serviced dozens of paying customers over the last four months, so they are losing money too. Because Auto & General has stalled this for so long, the dealership emailed them stating they are starting to charge storage fees. They gave them a waiting period. Auto & General ignored the email, and when I called to say I won't pay storage, they told me "it's not part of your policy." Why should I pay storage fees when my car is sitting open solely because of their incompetence?! • My Livelihood Destroyed: Because I earn most of my living through commissions on the road, being stranded since 23 July has cost me thousands in lost income. Even when I escalated to the National Financial Ombud Scheme (NFO Ref: 014...), Auto & General told them I hadn't exhausted their internal dispute process, even though I had already fought with their dispute managers. I kept quiet. At this point, I am left wondering why I am being treated with such disrespect and neglect. Is it because of my surname? Because I have been treated like I don't matter at all. My heart is bleeding. I am tired of the lies, the excuses, the out-of-pocket costs, the storage fee, and paying premiums for a stripped car gathering dust at a workshop. Auto & General, you have left me with no choice but to take this public. Stop hiding behind unreplied emails, hold Tradefed accountable, cover the storage fees caused by your delays, and deliver the brand-new engine and turbocharger you already paid for! #AutoAndGeneral #ConsumerRights #SouthAfrica #InsuranceNightmare

0
Replies (2)
More
dSmU
desember Sylvester mbatha User

1 reviews | Active since Nov 2026

20 Nov 2026, 15:42

thank you so much l happy at the end everything goes well with zanele shabalala was services goo...

thank you so much l happy at the end everything goes well with zanele shabalala was services good thanks

0
Replies (1)
More
NS
Nicolette S

1 reviews | Active since Sept 2018

20 Nov 2026, 14:54

Knowledgeable on the product

Knowledgeable on the product. Friendly to the customer. Offered other products

0
Replies (1)
More
WU
Winfreda U

1 reviews | Active since Nov 2026

20 Nov 2026, 13:04

Mannen Bloem was very understanding and helpful in all my queries also assured that all will be well

Mannen Bloem was very understanding and helpful in all my queries also assured that all will be well.

0
Replies (1)
More
NU
Ntokozo U

1 reviews | Active since Nov 2026

20 Nov 2026, 10:22

Zanale was very helpful with an update on my claim, splendid service from her😊

Zanale was very helpful with an update on my claim, splendid service from her😊

0
Replies (1)
More
LU
Leigh U

1 reviews | Active since Nov 2026

19 Nov 2026, 17:43

Incredible Service

Absolutely outstanding service. Consultants are so patient. Wide range of services. Calls are answered promptly. Knowledgeable consultants Really reasonably prices products Will never change

0
Replies (1)
More