Based on recent customer reviews, African Independent Brokers draws heavily negative feedback centred on billing and claims administration. Clients repeatedly report debit orders processed without clear consent, unexplained R950 and recurring fees, and deductions continuing long after policies were cancelled. Others describe rejected windscreen and accident claims, digital assessments instead of physical inspections, and unanswered emails to named consultants. A clear bright spot is broker Zelda, praised for patience, clear explanations, consistent follow up and going beyond her own portfolio to help policyholders resolve claims.
Replied to 17% of negative reviews
Reply time on negative reviews: 625h 45m
TrustIndex
3.3
Reply Time
504h 59m
NPS Score
-86
Recommended: Unlikely
Replied to 17% of negative reviews
Reply time on negative reviews: 625h 45m
Dec '25 - Nov '26
Frequently Asked Questions About African Independent Brokers
What do customers say about African Independent Brokers?
Based on recent customer reviews, African Independent Brokers draws heavily negative feedback centred on billing and claims administration. Clients repeatedly report debit orders processed without clear consent, unexplained R950 and recurring fees, and deductions continuing long after policies were cancelled. Others describe rejected windscreen and accident claims, digital assessments instead of physical inspections, and unanswered emails to named consultants. A clear bright spot is broker Zelda, praised for patience, clear explanations, consistent follow up and going beyond her own portfolio to help policyholders resolve claims.
Is African Independent Brokers trustworthy?
African Independent Brokers has a TrustIndex of 3.3 out of 10 on Hellopeter, based on 18 reviews in the last 12 months. They reply to 17% of negative reviews, typically within 625 hours 45 min. Hellopeter has tracked African Independent Brokers across 381 total reviews. How is the TrustIndex calculated? →
Recent reviews (18)
Used this business recently? Share your experience to help others decide.
Used this business recently? Share your experience to help others decide.
Share Your Experience1 reviews | Active since Feb 2022
I DO NOT RECOMMEND
I am a new client and, unfortunately, my experience with this company has been extremely disappointing. From the outset, I have received little to no assistance, and it appears that the company's priorities do not align with the best interests of its customers. A major concern is that debit order dates are scheduled without my knowledge or consent. I have requested the relevant call recordings to verify exactly when and where I allegedly agreed to the debit order date, as I do not recall providing such authorisation. In addition, the company has offered little to no meaningful resolution to my concerns. Communication has also been poor. I have sent multiple emails to Tamryn Shekyls and Mpho Majoro requesting clarification regarding my debit order date, but my queries have gone unanswered and I have received no meaningful assistance. Based on my experience, I cannot recommend this company. Customers deserve transparency, accountability, and responsive service. Unfortunately, I have experienced none of these. I would encourage prospective clients to think carefully before engaging with a company that fails to prioritise its customers and take responsibility when issues arise
1 reviews | Active since Feb 2022
I DO NOT RECOMMEND
I am a new client and, unfortunately, my experience with this company has been extremely disappointing. From the outset, I have received little to no assistance, and it appears that the company's priorities do not align with the best interests of its customers. A major concern is that debit order dates are scheduled without my knowledge or consent. I have requested the relevant call recordings to verify exactly when and where I allegedly agreed to the debit order date, as I do not recall providing such authorisation. In addition, the company has offered little to no meaningful resolution to my concerns. Communication has also been poor. I have sent multiple emails to Tamryn Shekyls and Mpho Majoro requesting clarification regarding my debit order date, but my queries have gone unanswered and I have received no meaningful assistance. Based on my experience, I cannot recommend this company. Customers deserve transparency, accountability, and responsive service. Unfortunately, I have experienced none of these. I would encourage prospective clients to think carefully before engaging with a company that fails to prioritise its customers and take responsibility when issues arise
1 reviews | Active since Jul 2026
Zelda Fitzpatrick
I called Independent Brokers yesterday just to add some changes on my insurance, I got a hold of Zelda and she was able to assist me with everything. She was friendly and told me everything I need to know about my insurance policy. Her patience in explaining and assistance we greatly appreciated by me.
1 reviews | Active since Jul 2026
Zelda Fitzpatrick
I called Independent Brokers yesterday just to add some changes on my insurance, I got a hold of Zelda and she was able to assist me with everything. She was friendly and told me everything I need to know about my insurance policy. Her patience in explaining and assistance we greatly appreciated by me.
1 reviews | Active since Dec 2010
Unauthorized debit order deduction
They deducted fees for a car insurance policy that I cancelled as I cancelled the deal for the new car I was trying to buy. I don't even remember being advised by them that they are charging me R950 to get quotations from them. They were suggested to me by the salesman I broke ties with. I want my money back. Please refund the below amount: 2026-05-25 ACB DEBIT:EXTERNAL AFRICANINDFEES067222 -R950.00
1 reviews | Active since Dec 2010
Unauthorized debit order deduction
They deducted fees for a car insurance policy that I cancelled as I cancelled the deal for the new car I was trying to buy. I don't even remember being advised by them that they are charging me R950 to get quotations from them. They were suggested to me by the salesman I broke ties with. I want my money back. Please refund the below amount: 2026-05-25 ACB DEBIT:EXTERNAL AFRICANINDFEES067222 -R950.00

