Faulty Yarra dinner plate

Bought 3 Country Road Yarra dinner plates from Fourways Mall and needed one more as I really loved them but Fourways ran out of stock. Drove all the way to Sandton City to get the plate, only realized when I was washing the plate that it is faulty. The slip is in the outside bin already because I believed so much that Country Road products go through quality assurance but I was very wrong.

I'm asking myself if it's worth it for me to go through a smelly bin to find the slip and spend the EXPENSIVE FUEL to return the plate? I'm so annoyed. The pricing on those items give no room for faults.