BSt
B Simelane theo.simelane

1 reviews | Active since Nov 2025

20 Nov 2025, 00:25

Poor service

I am writing this review with extreme frustration due to a persistent and unacceptable pattern of non-communication, severe delays, and fundamentally inadequate legal support from Scorpion Legal Protection. My experience since joining has been marked by significant distress, financial concern, and a complete failure by Scorpion to act in my best interests. 1. Total Failure of Follow-Up on Legal Advice (October 2025) Despite receiving formal written legal opinions from Scorpion's team, there has been zero action or follow-up: Legal Opinion to Lodge Complaint with LPC (Oct 2, 2025): I was advised to lodge a complaint with the Legal Practice Council (LPC) regarding my previous legal representation. As of today (November 20, 2025), I have received no updates, communication, or assistance in lodging this critical complaint. Notice to Open a New Case (Oct 12, 2025): I received a notice from Mr. Godfrey Netshi indicating I should be assisted in opening a new case. Again, I have received absolutely no support or contact from Scorpion's team to action this. My specific, written requests for updates and next steps have been entirely ignored, causing further distress and loss of valuable time. 2. History of Severe Delays and Lack of Assistance The current non-response is part of a larger, systemic problem: Months of Silence: I have experienced instances where it took four to five months for any response to my legal matters. Zero Assistance: Even when I manage to reach out, I often do not receive any substantive assistance to move my cases forward. This is a fundamental breach of the service promised by a legal protection provider. 3. Sub-Par Representation and Misconduct during CCMA Arbitration (July 2025) My original complaint, which triggered the ongoing issues and led to the need for a Legal Practice Council complaint, relates to the representation I received: Pressure to Settle & Exclusion: My representative, Mr. Stefan Nel (of JH Olivier Inc), presented a one-month settlement offer without consulting or preparing me and insisted it was the 'best outcome.' I felt pressured and signed under duress. Exclusion from Discussions: Mr. Nel privately conferred with the employer’s lawyer and conversed in Afrikaans during the proceedings, a language I do not understand, effectively excluding me from critical discussions. Failure to Provide Evidence: I have been repeatedly stonewalled in my attempts to obtain crucial documentation, specifically: Minutes from the initial CCMA meeting where a 3-month settlement was discussed. The recording that I witnessed Mr. Nel making with his phone during the arbitration session, which would verify my claims of misconduct and duress. Scorpion's internal response to my misconduct claims has been to simply state the matter is 'finalised as a settlement agreement was signed,' effectively dismissing serious allegations of lawyer misconduct and duress without proper investigation. Conclusion and Demand My experience with Scorpion Legal Protection is one of utter disappointment, negligence, and a failure to meet the most basic client support expectations. I am deeply concerned that my rights are not being protected and that Scorpion is prioritizing protecting the lawyers involved over addressing my legitimate complaints and acting on its own advice

0
Replies (2)
BSt
B Simelane theo.simelane's update20 Nov 2025, 08:31
Reviewer Update
HEADING: SCORPION LEGAL: 3 MONTHS OF SUSTAINED NEGLECT, LACK OF SUPPORT, AND DENIAL OF EVIDENCE DESPITE REPEATED URGENT DEMANDS
Note: The duration of unassisted struggle and being given the runaround is approximately 3 months (July 25, 2025, to October 16, 2025).
TB: "I don't know why do you want to assist me now if you have failed to assist me in those back months. When I call, the people I'm asking help from make a fool of me."
Jul 25, 2025: TB Action: Filed detailed complaint about attorney Stefan Nel's misconduct, exclusion, and forced settlement. Demand: Requested evidence.
Jul 25, 2025: Naledi Vilakazi (JH Olivier Inc.) Result: Denied misconduct; stated settlement was client's fault; closed file because TB signed.
Aug 15, 2025: TB Action: Formal complaint to Scorpion, LPC, and Tip-Off Line. Demand: Reiterated need for recording to prove misconduct.
Aug 19, 2025: Hazel P. Yotwana (Scorpion) Result: Closed complaint; stated the matter is finalized because the settlement was signed.
Aug 20, 2025: TB Action: Insisted the issue is misconduct, not settlement. Demand: Required confirmation that notes/recording were requested from attorneys.
Aug 22, 2025: Hazel P. Yotwana (Scorpion) Result: Denied access to records; stated the final decision to close the complaint stands.
Aug 22, 2025: King Seshwene (Scorpion) Action: Suggested asking the attorney for records to "put the matter to rest."
Sep 02, 2025: Stefan Nel (JH Olivier Inc.) Result: Unequivocally denied recording proceedings; confirmed TB signed settlement voluntarily after proceedings.
Sep 29, 2025: TB Action: Direct appeal to Senior Manager Mohamed Degam. Demand: Requested intervention and the missing evidence.
Sep 29, 2025: Mohamed Degam (Scorpion EO) Result: Acknowledged email: "We will investigate your concerns and revert to you as soon as possible."
Oct 2, 2025: TB Action: Sent FINAL DEMAND for service failure and **************. Demand: Written explanation, senior manager takeover, and immediate case commencement.
Oct 16, 2025: King Seshwene (Scorpion) Result: Advised that a Contact Centre agent would call to "assist you in lodging a complaint against the attorney." (Ignoring FINAL DEMAND points.)
Oct 16, 2025: TB Action: Follow-up noting no action taken on LPC complaint assistance or new case opening (advised by Mr. Godfrey Netshi).
Scorpion Legal Protection
Scorpion Legal Protection's reply02 Dec 2025, 07:50
Official
 
Dear Sir/Madam 

Thank you for contacting us.  We have noted your complaint and apologies for the break in service. 

Our dedicated contact person will contact you within 24 working hours. 

Should you require any further assistance please do not hesitate contact our Customer Care department on ***or send us a WhatsApp on *** 

We sincerely appreciate your feedback. 

Best Regards 

Customer Care Department