1 reviews | Active since Mar 2013
Pathetic
I am extremely disappointed with the way Sage is treating its existing customers.
I have been using Sage Business Cloud Accounting as a business customer, and I have now been presented with a notification stating that I will be redirected to a new Sage Account login system.
According to Sage, existing users will now be required to create or use a Sage Account, enable Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA), receive OTP verification for every login, and approve login attempts before gaining access.
Sage further states that this single login system will eventually replace existing in-product logins.
My question is simple:
Who gave Sage the right to unilaterally change the conditions under which existing customers purchased and use their services?
Customers entered into an agreement to use Sage's accounting software. We did not necessarily agree to every new login requirement, account integration or authentication arrangement that Sage may decide to introduce at a later stage.
I have no objection to reasonable security improvements. However, there is a fundamental difference between improving security and imposing new mandatory conditions on existing customers without providing a meaningful choice or explaining the contractual and legal basis for doing so.
Under South African common law, contractual terms cannot simply be varied unilaterally unless the existing agreement provides for such a variation or the parties agree to it.
Furthermore, Section 48 of the Consumer Protection Act 68 of 2008 addresses unfair, unreasonable and unjust contractual terms, where applicable.
POPIA also requires personal information to be processed lawfully, reasonably and for legitimate purposes. Customers are entitled to understand what personal information is collected, how it is processed, and whether additional account arrangements involve further processing or sharing of their information.
Sage cannot simply hide behind the words "improved security" without properly explaining the implications for existing customers.
Answer these questions: Where in the original customer agreement does Sage obtain the contractual authority to impose this new mandatory login arrangement on existing customers? Did Sage obtain existing customers' agreement to this material change, or is Sage simply imposing it as a condition of continued access? What happens to customers who do not wish to create or link a new Sage Account? What personal information is collected through the new Sage Account system, and with whom is that information shared? What alternative login arrangements are available to customers who do not wish to use this new system? What protection do existing customers have against losing access to their accounting records and business information if they decline to accept the new arrangements?
The bigger issue is the attitude of large software companies towards their customers.
Once a customer has invested time, money and business records into a particular platform, the supplier effectively has considerable control over that customer's ability to continue operating.
It is unacceptable for suppliers to treat customers as though they have no say in decisions that directly affect their businesses.
A customer should not be forced into accepting every new condition simply because the supplier controls the software.
I expect Sage to provide a clear explanation of its contractual authority, the legal basis for these changes, and the alternatives available to existing customers.
Customers pay for a service. They do not surrender all their rights and choices in the process.
I would appreciate a proper response from Sage rather than a standard corporate explanation about improved security.
