GD
Gloria D

1 reviews | Active since Feb 2018

13 Mar 2022, 18:11

MAKRO RCS ***** AND ********** - INSIDE JOB SUSPECTED!

I WILL NOT PAY ANY CENT TO MAKRO RCS UNTIL MY CASE IS RESOLVED.

I am very frustrated and disappointed in the manner that MAKRO RCS is treating a new clients and ********** activities on their accounts. Since I reported a ********** Transaction off my account physically and formally on 09 & 10 February 2022, there is nothing meaningful communicated or solution offered to my issue. The only thing they are doing is harassing me to pay my account which is now in their Collection Department and email reminding me how long it takes to investigate or they escalated the matter.

DETAILS AND TIMEFRAMES 1.28 Jan 2022: I enquired about Makro Credit Application Process at Makro Crown Mines Branch. After following their instructions, I app**** for Makro RCS Credit Card. Application, Approval, Card Collection and Activation was done same day. 2.29 Jan 2022: I purchased items amounting to R2827.50 and it was followed by sms from Makro confirming purchase. 3.05 Feb 2022: I purchased items valued at R1734.50 at Makro Crown Mines, again followed by sms confirmation. 4.06 Feb 2022: I purchased items valued at R1072.90 at Makro Crown Mines, again followed by sms confirmation. 5.09 FEBRUARY 2022: *********** TRANSACTION MADE OFF. I WAS AT HOME WHEN I RECEIVED SMS "CONFIRMING A PURCHASE OF ITEMS VALUED AT R19550.66 AT PICK N PAY". Initially, I thought it was a delayed/ duplicate message from my last purchase made on 06 February 2022. After re-reading the message, I realised that it was *****. I drove as fast as I could from Doornfontein to Makro Crown Mines. *I asked for the relevant manager and I could not be assisted immediately until I made it clear that I was not leaving the store until my matter was attended to. Instead of the “Risk Manager” explaining the Complaint/***** process to me, he left me there, saying he was going to call the police to report the “***** Case”. Instead of him giving me feedback, he sent one of his subordinates to dismiss me, saying “the store was closing, and I should leave”. After stating that, “I was not leaving without a proper Dispute process explained to me”, instead of calling the police as earlier informed by him, the “Risk Manager called the ADT security guards on me. I repeatedly told everyone present, that I was not leaving until my issue was properly handled. I had already called my family for moral support. My younger brother and my elder daughter arrived and they were refused entry to the store. *After pressure from us and telling them we will expose and report them on all social media platforms, the “Risk Manager” ended up calling a ZN (initials) to address us over the phone. We then reached an agreement to meet the next morning to formally lodge a complaint. 6.10 Feb 2022: I, my younger brother and my daughter met with ZN at Makro Crown Mines as agreed. As stated by him, he was joined in that meeting by two of his colleagues dealing with ***** cases. Discussions were held and I was requested to complete some form to formally lodge a complaint as per their internal processes. I was also told that my account would be frozen/ temporarily closed to avoid further ********** activities. 7.17 Feb 2022: I received a text message reading thus “Congratulation on your 1st Makro account card purchase. Your debit order has not been received. Just a reminder to make payment...”. 8.18 Feb 2022: I received a text message reading thus, “Your Makro debit order for R1565.53 returned unpaid. Pay today....". 9. 20 Feb 2022: I made a Follow Up with Makro as well as notifying other parties of my complaint. I requested Makro RCS Management to provide me with (a) Progress Report and Evidence that my case was being investigated (b) Proof (Case No) that they had opened a ***** Case with SAPS on my behalf as they claimed (c) To be open and transparent from w.r.t this ******** activity using my details (d) To ensure that my Credit Profile and Credit Score is updated accordingly with all the Credit Bureau in the country as this will impact negatively on my personal & professional life (e) To revise my Makro Card E-Statement & ensure it contains accurate info before their Payment Due Date, which was 01 March 2022. Until such time, I would not make any payments (f) I had informed them of decision to cancel my Debit Order Payment Option & switch to Pay In-Store Option (g) To remove all charges/ penalties/ records related to this ********** Case under my account (h) Future contact with me from 20 February 2022 should strictly be in written form to avoid further risk (i) I shared with them the main reason I desperately needed closure to this matter, which is my current medical condition due several unpleasant occurrences which triggered my stress and threatened my health.

I sent my Makro RCS Complaint to ***; ***; ***; Crown Mines Credit ***; ***; ***; ***; *** and and copied ***; ***; ***; *** Since I regard this matter as ugent, I requested Makro RCS to prioritise the issue and I gave them 5-working days to respond with a solution.

PROGRESS TO DATE: 11 March 2022, 07:20 I received an email. From RCS. *** and letter attached, my “current balance” is R5, 747.03, placing “my account” in arrears. The arrears and the instalment amount to R1,949.06. Same day, at 16H42, I received an SMS reading thus,”MS G PINKY DISEMELO. Your MAKRO acc is Overdue & in Collections. Pay R1949.06 today...” 13 March 2022, 03:30 (Nagana fela). "Ms Gloria Pinky Disemelo A reminder that a R1,949.06 payment is due on your Makro account. Call 086.....29 or Whatsapp 06650...98 for assistance. RESPONSES FROM SOME OF THE ABOVE RECIPIENTS:

Feb 2022, 10:19, “As previously communicated with you that the investigation takes up to 21 working days to be concluded. For further assistance/ follow up please call our ***** dept ***). PS (Initials) (Makro)

20 Feb 2022,13:29 “…please be advised that your query has been escalated to the relevant department for further assistance for further assistance. We will revert to you as soon as we receive feedback. Alternatively you can contact the Makro Credit division on the below: RCS call centre: ***, RCS Email address: ***

21 Feb 2022, 11:41 *** NM (Case Admin), “Kindly be advised that this office lacks jurisdiction to entertain this complaint as it does not relate to rendering of a financial service in terms of the Financial Advisory and Intermediary Services Act 37 of 2002. Northwithstanding this, and in accordance with our commitment to promote consumer protection, we have forwarded your complaint to the National Credit Regulator. The contact person and details are: MM, Tel: 011554…., Fax: 011554….. You can expect to hear from them.

21 Feb 2022, 13:57 ombud (***, copied fg…***, “We have forwarded your email to Ms FG at our call centre who will be in contact with you to get additional information and to log a complaint for you. It will then be allocated to case manager for investigation. Further communication will follow upon receipt of a reply from the Credit provider From DG Credit Ombud.

22 Feb 2022, 10:07 Complaint. *** – “We herewith acknowledge receipt of your complaint. Your complaint reference number is ACT-12…..0. We have escalated the complaint to the relevant department for further assistance. Should you have any additional enquiries please do not hesitate to contact our Customer Service Department telephonically on ***or via email: ***

24 Feb 2022, 13:49 I sent all the required information and supporting documents both telephonically and through email to SM creditombud.org.za 24 Feb 2022 14:13 from above recipient, “Thank You. Documents received and attached to your complaint. We will revert as soon as we receive feedback from creditor. 11 March 2022 07:20 From RCS ***, reply to RCS *** Email requesting me to find correspondence dated March 2022, attached to this email….. On the Attached Letter bearing my Names, an Account No and Balance of R25747.03, “…Noted that your recent payment has not been received yet, placing your account in arrears. The arrears and the instalment amount to R1949.06. I am rejecting this statement, just like the first one after ********** Activity was carried out off my account. 11 March 2022 16:42 +***, “MS G PINKY DISEMELO. Your MAKRO acc is Overdue and in Collections. Pay R1949.06 today. Pay via Easypay nbr ***…..Call *** Ref 348….4”.

ANY PERSON WHO MAY ASSIST, I AM KINDLY REQUESTING FOR FURTHER GUIDANCE TO SPEED UP THIS MATTER!!! I STILL REPEAT THAT THE ********** TRANSACTION THAT OCCURED ON 09 FEBRUARY 2022 AT PROTEA NORTH PICK N PAY WAS NOT CARRIED OUT BY ME IN ANY PHYSICAL OR ONLINE FORM. DESPITE ALL EVIDENCE REQUESTED BY MAKRO RCS AND PROVIDED BY ME, THEY ARE STILL HARASSING ME AND DEMANDING PAYMENTS FROM ME. TO MAKE IT WORSE, SINCE THIS ********** ACTIVITY MY CREDIT SCORE HAS DROPPED WITH 6 POINTS. PLEASE HELP URGENTLY!!!

0
Replies (4)
RCS
RCS's reply14 Mar 2022, 15:07
Official
Good day 

We herewith acknowledge receipt of your complaint.

We have escalated your complaint to the relevant department for further assistance.

Should you have any additional enquiries please do not hesitate to contact our Customer Service Department telephonically on ***or via e-mail: ***

Kind Regards

RCS Group
GD
Gloria D's update29 Mar 2022, 09:52
Reviewer Update
RESPONSE TO RCS ***** INVESTIGATION FEEDBACK
RCS – MAKRO SENIOR MANAGERS

I STILL MAINTAIN, I WILL NOT PAY YOU ANY CENT UNTIL YOU REMOVE ALL INFORMATION RELATING TO A ********** TRANSACTION MADE ON MY ACCOUNT - AN INSIDE JOB SUSPECTED!

It is very disappointing to have such an unfruitful and ************* brand like RCS – Makro Brands operating in our homeland! As previously mentioned in my complaint letter dated, 19 February 2022, I hold a Makro RCS Credit Card Number 50*********. As previously mentioned, I lodged a complaint both physically and formally on 09 & 10 February 2022, that a ********** Transaction of R19, 550.66 was made from my Makro RCS Credit Card at Protea North Pick 'n Pay, while I had my card with me. I lodged a dispute at your Makro Crown Mines Branch, and I stated to your so-called Risk Managers that, this transaction was not carried out by me in any physical or online form. I also mentioned that this was a ******** activity utilizing my personal details and I requested them to kindly stop all payments, transactions, or any other related activity and freeze my account for all online and offline purchases/ transactions until the date that this matter is completely resolved.
As previously mentioned, RCS – Makro ***** Department has been unhelpful, inconsiderate, and unreliable since I reported the matter to them on the above-mentioned dates. The only thing I was instructed to do at Makro Crown Mines Branch on 10 February 2022 was to complete RCS – ***** Department Dispute Declaration Form. From then on, there was no communication or update provided until I made follow-ups. The RCS - Makro *********** staff members would only inform me that they had escalated the matter to the relevant department. So far, there is nothing meaningful communicated or solution offered to my issue. What aggravates me the most is the harassment I am suffering from RCS – Makro through telephonic calls and emails, demanding account payment which they are aware that the amount on the Account Statement includes inflated and incorrect figures relating to the ********** Transaction reported to them. To add to my frustrations, they have now mentioned that “My Account” has been handed over to their Collections Department.
In my previous Complaint Letter, dated 19 February 2022 to RCS - Makro Management, I had mentioned a few recommendations for resolving my matter completely and returning my life to normal, but clearly, RCS – Makro purposely ignored them to inflict more pain on me and cause me more frustrations by dragging this matter unnecessarily. It is very disheartening after such a long wait to receive suitable solutions and you just receive a text message. I received a message on Thursday, 24 March 2022 at 17H12 +*** reading thus, “Dear Ms Disemelo. The investigation on your Makro card has been finalized. Your new secure card is ready for collection from your nearest Makro store free of charge. Please take your Green barcoded or Smart ID card with when collecting your new card. RCS *****”.
I AM THEREFORE APPEALING TO RCS - MAKRO TO PAY ATTENTION TO THE FOLLOWING IN COMPLETELY RESOLVING MY MATTER:
(a) As stated in my previous letter, dated 19 February 2022, I have in numerous accounts mentioned that I DO NOT WANT ANYTHING TO DO WITH RCS - MAKRO CREDIT CARDS EVER, NOW YOU ARE TELLING ME TO COME TO COLLECT A NEW SECURE CARD WHICH I NEVER ASKED FOR. PLEASE MAKE SURE THAT YOU DESTROY THAT USELESS CARD OF YOURS.
(b) As you have indicated that "you have finalized the investigation on my Makro card", please provide me with a Detailed Report on what had transpired regarding that ********** Transaction; who authorized the transaction without my consent, and who purchased the items.
(c) As previously mentioned by the Makro Crown Mines Branch Risk Managers that a ******** Case of ********** Transaction would be opened then with the South African Police Service (SAPS), kindly provide me with copies of the Case, as well as the Case Number.
(d) RCS – Makro should retract all false and inaccurate information relating to this ********** Transaction submitted to all Credit Bureaus and reflected under my Credit Profile and already tempered with my Credit Score. This is clearly defamation of my character which necessitates action from recurring. I also do not want to lose personal and professional opportunities because of your negligence and recklessness.
(e) As previously stated in my Complaint Letter dated 19 February 2022, I rejected:
(i) Makro Card E-Statement – February 2022, emailed to me on 16 February 2022 (dated 10 February 2022) at 1****, by ***.
In addition, I am rejecting the following:
(ii) LettersEmail_E-Statement_Mar2022_20265.pdf, emailed to me by *** on 11 March 2022, 07H20 (dated 10 March 2022).
(iii) LettersEmail_E-Statement_Mar2022_62.pdf, emailed to me by *** on 17 March 2022, 01H28 (dated 16 March 2022).
Reason for Rejection: All the above documents sent to me contains incorrect information and ********** transaction of R19,550.66. This implies that even the instalment and interest calculated are incorrect.
(f) As stated in the previous correspondences, the only transactions I can account for are as follows:
(i) 29 January 2022, Saturday: I purchased items at Makro Crown Mines. Text message received at 13H28 – +***, “Makro Card: Thank you for purchasing at Makro crown min on card …6160 for R2827.50 on 29-01-2022 at 1327. Avail CR R27165. Queries-call ***”.
(ii) 05 February 2022, Saturday: I purchased items at Makro Crown Mines. Text message received at 16H39 – +***, “Makro Card: Thank you for purchasing at Makro crown min on card …6160 for R1734.50 on 05-02-2022 at 1639. Avail CR R25431. Queries-call ***”.
(iii) 06 February 2022, Sunday: I purchased items at Makro Crown Mines. Text message received at 13H00 – +***, “Makro Card: Thank you for purchasing at Makro crown min on card …6160 for R1072.90 on 06-02-2022 at 1300. Avail CR R24358. Queries-call ***”.
(g) Considering the above, I will not make any payment to RCS – Makro until my matter is completely resolved. In my previous letter I had requested RCS – Makro to ensure that my Makro Card E-Statement was revised correctly and bore accurate information before your Payment Due Date, which was 01 March 2022. RCS – Makro should remove all charges/ penalties/ records related to this ******** Activity under my name. Until such time, I will not make any payments.
(h) In my previous letter I had indicated that based on this traumatic ********** activity on my account, I had taken a decision regarding the Payment Option. I asked to cancel my initial Option – Debit Order and I opted for the Pay In-Store Option once my matter is completely resolved.
(i) I had also stated that I would prefer our mode of communication to exclude telephonic calls and strictly be in a written form to avoid further risk of being compromised again.
I would like to express my gratitude for all work done to ensure that the matter was investigated and finalised as mentioned by you. Trust is therefore expressed that, the provision of all the above information I requested will be effortless and quicker. As mentioned before, I am currently battling mental health issues and I do not want you adding to my stress anymore. Really this matter should have been long resolved since most people are complaining about ********** Transactions done on RCS Credit Cards. Therefore, you should by now be mastering how best to address these issues.
I will be awaiting your response in anticipation!
Yours Sincerely,

Gloria Pinky Disemelo
RCS
RCS's reply04 Apr 2022, 11:31
Official
Good day 

Thank you for your email.

Your complaint is currently still in progress and feedback will be provided once resolved.

Please accept my apologies for the delay.

Should you have any additional enquiries please do not hesitate to contact our Customer Service Department telephonically on ***or via e-mail: *** 

Kind Regards,

RCS group.
GD
Gloria D's update20 Sept 2022, 10:13
Reviewer Update
TO: MAKRO SENIOR MANAGERS
As you are well aware by now, I am holding a Makro RCS Credit Card Number ***. As communicated to you on many occasions using different mode of communication (Email, Facebook, Hello Peter, etc.), I want to permanently close my account with immediate effect. I received my Statement on 16 September 2022 at 11H58 (***) and my balance was R3,847.08. On 17 September 2022, I made a payment of R3, 847.08 at your Makro Crown Mines Branch.
After payment I communicated my decision to close the account to the Makro Cashier who was assisting me then. She then referred me to your Customer Service. I also requested them to close the account with immediate effect. The person who assisted me indicated that I should have requested a Settlement before payment (of which I was not aware of before making payment). She tried to check what the Settlement Amount was and it did not retrieve the requested information. I am therefore writing to you to request the following:
(a) Indicate what is outstanding.
(b) Close my account with immediate effect.
(c) Deactivate and destroy the Credit Card that you disregarded my wishes and went ahead to generate it for yourselves (not me).
(d) Provide me with my Paid Letter.
I would like to reiterate that I do not want anything that tie me with either Makro or RCS in future, so please do not even send me any future communication, adverti*****t, etc. after closing my account.

All correspondences regarding my request above should be in writing/ email. I do not trust you all after your ********** Activity on my account that you kept on covering up.
I will be awaiting your response in anticipation!