Based on recent customer reviews, Poetry Stores is drawing sharp criticism for online order fulfilment and after-sales support. Shoppers describe parcels marked delivered but never received, orders cancelled without explanation, and refunds processed only in part. Branch experiences at Sandton, Pavilion, Eastgate and Watercrest include unanswered phones, promised callbacks that never come, and exchange requests handled with suspicion. A smaller group praises the brand warmly, citing smooth online shopping, easy returns and genuinely friendly shop assistants, suggesting service quality swings widely between individual stores and staff members.
TrustIndex
2.2
NPS Score
-100
Recommended: Unlikely
Dec '25 - Nov '26
Frequently Asked Questions About Poetry Stores
What do customers say about Poetry Stores?
Based on recent customer reviews, Poetry Stores is drawing sharp criticism for online order fulfilment and after-sales support. Shoppers describe parcels marked delivered but never received, orders cancelled without explanation, and refunds processed only in part. Branch experiences at Sandton, Pavilion, Eastgate and Watercrest include unanswered phones, promised callbacks that never come, and exchange requests handled with suspicion. A smaller group praises the brand warmly, citing smooth online shopping, easy returns and genuinely friendly shop assistants, suggesting service quality swings widely between individual stores and staff members.
Is Poetry Stores trustworthy?
Poetry Stores has a TrustIndex of 2.2 out of 10 on Hellopeter, based on 17 reviews in the last 12 months. Hellopeter has tracked Poetry Stores across 259 total reviews. How is the TrustIndex calculated? →
Recent reviews (17)
Used this business recently? Share your experience to help others decide.
Used this business recently? Share your experience to help others decide.
Share Your Experience1 reviews | Active since Sept 2014
Disgusting service
I visited your Walmer Park store on the 27/10/2026 bought a dress instore and the second one I did not get the size I wanted in store but obtained in online but the payment was done right there and then and I was advised that it will take 3-5 working days. Which I had no problem with. On the 02/11/2026 I received an email from Andrea Matthews which I was then advised that there was a problem with my order and there was a slight delay so they are requesting a further 3-5 working days for my order to arrive. Again I had no problem. I heard nothing after that until I decided on the 13/11/2026 to physically visit the store again, which by the way is 20km from my house, to enquire about my order and when I got there I was advised they could not see the order and they have had system problem the entire week so they will give me a call once that it sorted. I, again, heard nothing from them. On Monday the 16/11/2026 I decided to give the store a call again, USING MY OWN AIRTIME. I was on a call for a full 9 minutes and 34 seconds with them, advising me that they do not have my order. I spoke to the store leader named Raeesa Begg who requested to give me a call back as she will need to call the online dept and enquire what is happening to the order. She then called me back and advised that there was a problem with my order which meant that I will receive a refund. She advised that I will receive an email requesting my banking details so that I get a refund from the payment I had made. The time was 16/11/2026 at 14:43. Till today at 19:56 I still have not received the 'said' email. Besides wasting petrol to get to the store and then again wasting airtime calling the store, I have been inconvenienced to the max. I am writing this email with frustration not only about the dress that I have not received and still will not have but my funds that I have paid are still with your company. I need my money back. Not only for the dress that I have paid but have to be reimbursed for the waste of time that I experienced to and from your store just to be told that they cannot find my order. I will also write on Hello Peter as it seems that you guys do not care about your customers. I trust this will be resolved ASAP and I will be get my petrol and airtime reimbursed as this was not my problem and yet I am the one sufferring.
1 reviews | Active since Sept 2014
Disgusting service
I visited your Walmer Park store on the 27/10/2026 bought a dress instore and the second one I did not get the size I wanted in store but obtained in online but the payment was done right there and then and I was advised that it will take 3-5 working days. Which I had no problem with. On the 02/11/2026 I received an email from Andrea Matthews which I was then advised that there was a problem with my order and there was a slight delay so they are requesting a further 3-5 working days for my order to arrive. Again I had no problem. I heard nothing after that until I decided on the 13/11/2026 to physically visit the store again, which by the way is 20km from my house, to enquire about my order and when I got there I was advised they could not see the order and they have had system problem the entire week so they will give me a call once that it sorted. I, again, heard nothing from them. On Monday the 16/11/2026 I decided to give the store a call again, USING MY OWN AIRTIME. I was on a call for a full 9 minutes and 34 seconds with them, advising me that they do not have my order. I spoke to the store leader named Raeesa Begg who requested to give me a call back as she will need to call the online dept and enquire what is happening to the order. She then called me back and advised that there was a problem with my order which meant that I will receive a refund. She advised that I will receive an email requesting my banking details so that I get a refund from the payment I had made. The time was 16/11/2026 at 14:43. Till today at 19:56 I still have not received the 'said' email. Besides wasting petrol to get to the store and then again wasting airtime calling the store, I have been inconvenienced to the max. I am writing this email with frustration not only about the dress that I have not received and still will not have but my funds that I have paid are still with your company. I need my money back. Not only for the dress that I have paid but have to be reimbursed for the waste of time that I experienced to and from your store just to be told that they cannot find my order. I will also write on Hello Peter as it seems that you guys do not care about your customers. I trust this will be resolved ASAP and I will be get my petrol and airtime reimbursed as this was not my problem and yet I am the one sufferring.
1 reviews | Active since Mar 2019
No update from online purchase.
Poetry online delivery service is sooo terrible, I ordered online last week Friday, got a confirmation email, today is Wednesday theres absolutely no update on how or my order is. I'm mean really? Just an update would be appreciated , you need to do much better with your online delivery. If I had ordered from woolies I would have probably received my order yesterday or even on Monday. Soooo disappointing.
1 reviews | Active since Mar 2019
No update from online purchase.
Poetry online delivery service is sooo terrible, I ordered online last week Friday, got a confirmation email, today is Wednesday theres absolutely no update on how or my order is. I'm mean really? Just an update would be appreciated , you need to do much better with your online delivery. If I had ordered from woolies I would have probably received my order yesterday or even on Monday. Soooo disappointing.
1 reviews | Active since Nov 2026
My money matters to.
Poetry canal walk is so messed up. Every time i am there im obviously followed around like as though I am a *****. The actual audacity, i ask if they need anything since they are towering over me . So ****** too cause it only happens to black people. I pointed it out the last time I was there and turned out it was the manager every time that was following me around. Shame on them. The only reason I bought stuff still was because the Poetry stuff at my nearest branch big bag and super nice and professional. Fix it. Its messed up.
1 reviews | Active since Nov 2026
My money matters to.
Poetry canal walk is so messed up. Every time i am there im obviously followed around like as though I am a *****. The actual audacity, i ask if they need anything since they are towering over me . So ****** too cause it only happens to black people. I pointed it out the last time I was there and turned out it was the manager every time that was following me around. Shame on them. The only reason I bought stuff still was because the Poetry stuff at my nearest branch big bag and super nice and professional. Fix it. Its messed up.
1 reviews | Active since Dec 2021
*****
Poetry Northridge Bloemfontein I had my original slips. When I return goods to branch, the Manager subtract a previously credited item on the recently transactions amount. When I show them that they can't take money return on a previous return, because Poetry now have the money paid on the item as well as the fiscal item, the manager had no reason to give my full amount for the items return. The difference short on the return R798.00. It is *****. I phone the Poetry Head Officie in the branch for assistance. They told me they will phone me back. Till now no response
1 reviews | Active since Dec 2021
*****
Poetry Northridge Bloemfontein I had my original slips. When I return goods to branch, the Manager subtract a previously credited item on the recently transactions amount. When I show them that they can't take money return on a previous return, because Poetry now have the money paid on the item as well as the fiscal item, the manager had no reason to give my full amount for the items return. The difference short on the return R798.00. It is *****. I phone the Poetry Head Officie in the branch for assistance. They told me they will phone me back. Till now no response
1 reviews | Active since Sept 2016
Service Par Excellence
I thought I would take a moment and mention the outstanding experience I have received from all three Poetry stores I engaged with over the past 3 weeks. The service is so refreshing. Nothing is a problem; online shopping is smooth and returns done with a smile. The ladies in the shops are also great to have around, with a friendly smile. Well done, Poetry!
1 reviews | Active since Sept 2016
Service Par Excellence
I thought I would take a moment and mention the outstanding experience I have received from all three Poetry stores I engaged with over the past 3 weeks. The service is so refreshing. Nothing is a problem; online shopping is smooth and returns done with a smile. The ladies in the shops are also great to have around, with a friendly smile. Well done, Poetry!
1 reviews | Active since Dec 2019
Horrible!
Poetry has the worst customer service for what is supposed to be a premium store. The worse part, is that Sandton is the worst. With a phone line that always has issues and hardly hearing what the other person is saying because it's just noisy. What they would do when you ask for item availability through another poetry - store to store, they lie and say the item isn't there. Also when they promise to call you back when you need assistance, they just don't. I wonder if the brand actually cares about its customers as I'm clearly not the first person annoyed by poor service. Rather buy your items from brands that actually care and save yourself the heartache.
1 reviews | Active since Dec 2019
Horrible!
Poetry has the worst customer service for what is supposed to be a premium store. The worse part, is that Sandton is the worst. With a phone line that always has issues and hardly hearing what the other person is saying because it's just noisy. What they would do when you ask for item availability through another poetry - store to store, they lie and say the item isn't there. Also when they promise to call you back when you need assistance, they just don't. I wonder if the brand actually cares about its customers as I'm clearly not the first person annoyed by poor service. Rather buy your items from brands that actually care and save yourself the heartache.

