AG
Alison G

1 reviews | Active since Jul 2011

21 Apr 2026, 13:24

Shocking Old Mutual error costs member over R100-000 - as yet - ZERO accountability from this company.

Old Mutual has made a catastrophic error with my provident fund that has cost me over R100,000.

I gave a simple, standard instruction: withdraw a certain, taxable amount, and transfer the remaining bulk into a new provident fund (non-taxable). Instead, Old Mutual incorrectly declared my full pension to SARS as a taxable withdrawal, resulting in a 32% tax rate.

This is not a minor mistake — it shows a fundamental failure in handling retirement funds.

To make matters worse, a consultant (Thosiza) argued that this incorrect declaration was “correct,” and a manager (Dillan Petersen) who was meant to contact me last Thursday has not responded at all.

I am now left with a massive financial loss and no accountability.

I have formally escalated this matter and expect urgent correction and full accountability. If not resolved immediately, I will be taking this further with regulatory authorities. This business is clearly not trustworthy with anyone's money.

Absolutely unacceptable.

0
Replies (3)
Old Mutual
Old Mutual's reply21 Apr 2026, 13:56
Official
Good day

We acknowledge receipt of your review and sincerely apologise for the service experience you encountered. We are committed to investigating this matter thoroughly and will make direct contact with you during business hours should further information be required.

Kind regards
Old Mutual Complaints Management
AG
Alison G's update04 May 2026, 11:27
Reviewer Update
This started on 14 April and AS YET there is NO PROGRESS on this query. Emails go unanswered. Old Mutual Complaints Dept promised to revert within 5 days. This time came and went and there has been no contact. Dillon Petersen AND Yolandi have ignored my emails. Cima was supposed to send the tax directives to me last week. It did not happen. If this absolute lack of ability is how Old Mutual deals with people's life savings, costing them over R100-000 through bungling, NOONE in South Africa should be trusting this business. I await an update. As I have stated in my emails - my next step will be to get the Financial Regulator involved.
Old Mutual
Old Mutual's reply04 May 2026, 14:50
Official
Good day

We acknowledge receipt of your review and sincerely apologise for the service experience you encountered. We are committed to investigating this matter thoroughly and will make direct contact with you during business hours should further information be required.

Kind regards
Old Mutual Complaints Management