AB
Aletta B

1 reviews | Active since Jul 2011

10 Dec 2025, 12:49

Formal Complaint Regarding Unresolved Key-Loss Claim and Poor Service

I am writing to lodge a formal complaint regarding the unacceptable handling of my insurance claim relating to my lost car keys and the subsequent towing of my vehicle. I have been a loyal client who pays my premiums on time every month, yet the service I am currently receiving is extremely disappointing and is causing me tremendous stress.

Since reporting the loss of my car keys, the claim has taken an unreasonable amount of time to process. Instead of handling the matter directly and professionally, I am being contacted repeatedly by different agents and representatives, including people from the dealership (William Hunt), who keep giving me quotes and information that only adds to the confusion.

Furthermore, I have been informed that the replacement keys will be provided by a locksmith rather than through the original manufacturer. This is unacceptable. I expect the insurance to replace my lost keys with proper original keys, not inferior alternatives. I also reject the proposal of being paid out in cash, as this amount will not be sufficient to resolve the issue. It is the insurer’s responsibility to sort out this matter on my behalf, as per the policy I pay for.

The continuous calls, lack of coordination, and failure to resolve the claim are causing me significant distress. I therefore request the following:

Immediate and proper handling of my claim.

Replacement of my lost keys with original manufacturer keys.

An end to unnecessary and repetitive calls from multiple agents.

Clear communication from a single responsible claims handler.

Should this poor service continue, I will have no choice but to consider cancelling my insurance and raising the matter further.

I expect a prompt response and resolution.

0
Replies (2)
1st for Women
1st for Women's reply10 Dec 2025, 12:52
Official
 
Hi Aletta, 
 
We are disappointed to hear about your service experience. 
 
Kindly note that your matter has been escalated to the relevant team to look into. 
 
Kind Regards,
The 1st for Women Team 
AB
Aletta B's update12 Dec 2025, 12:56
Reviewer Update

After waiting for over a month, I received a quote of R6,800, which contains no specific information about my vehicle. I contacted William Hunt to confirm the accuracy of this quote, as I have lost trust in the way First for Women Insurance is handling my claim. The quote I received was from a Roodeport dealer, while my car is located at your Centurion dealer. The Centurion dealer provided a completely different quote of R12,000.
This discrepancy, coupled with constant contradictory information, has caused extreme frustration and disappointment. The proposed deposit of R4,000 into my account is far below the actual cost of repairs at the dealer where my car is, and the quote provided appears misleading and insufficient.
I request that First for Women Insurance:
  1. Review my claim urgently and provide a correct, detailed, and verified quote from the dealer where my car is currently located.
  2. Explain why there is such inconsistency in the quotes and why the information provided to me has been inaccurate.
  3. Ensure a full, fair, and timely settlement of my claim in accordance with my policy coverage.
I expect a written response within 7 business days, detailing the steps that will be taken to resolve this matter. Should this issue not be addressed promptly and appropriately, I will escalate my complaint to the relevant regulatory authorities. I am extremely disappointed with the service I have received and trust that First for Women Insurance will take immediate action to resolve this matter.