PS
Peet S

1 reviews | Active since Apr 2015

03 Nov 2021, 20:15

Very bad experience with first and definitely last claim.

Would have given them a zero if I could. I am a client of New National through a broker. I have cars, household and all risk items insured with them, which includes my wife's wedding ring. The ring was custom designed and manufactured especially for us. The ring was valued for +-R20k and it was insured for R20k. The ring was stipulated in the policy as a designers ring. My wife unfortunately lost her ring. I claimed it and was instructed to supply them with a replacement quotation which was for +-R22k from the original manufacturer. I was contacted shortly after by an assessor, and received an "Agreement of Loss" document to sign with an adjusted claim value of +-R15500 as they can get exactly the same ring made at a different manufacturer for cheaper. I was informed that they can choose which supplier they want to use to replace what was lost. First of all, you cannot replace a designer ring without using the original designer and manufacturer. It would sure be great if an insurance claim for the loss of the Mona Lisa could be met with replica by some knock off artist. Secondly, I insured the ring for an amount that was indicated on the valuation certificate and paid a premium for said amount. How on earth can you as an insurer then just decide that even though I paid premium on the valuation amount, you will just be paying out 75%?

I am extremely dissatisfied with your service and will be canceling my insurance with you in the very near future!!

0
Replies (8)
New National Assurance Company Limited
New National Assurance Company Limited's reply04 Nov 2021, 08:42
Official
Good day, 

 

We acknowledge receipt of your complaint and confirm that we are looking into the matter. Once we have perused all documentation, we will accordingly provide you with the necessary feedback.

 

Regards

Market Conduct Department
PS
Peet S's update04 Nov 2021, 14:24
Reviewer Update
Pleas tend to this matter urgently. I see from other HelloPeter Complaints your turnaround time on response is about a week. I have been battling this for 3weeks now.
New National Assurance Company Limited
New National Assurance Company Limited's reply05 Nov 2021, 13:33
Official
Dear Mr Swart, 

We refer to your complaint submitted on the 04/11/2021.

Please note that in terms of the policy wording under the general terms and conditions of your policy, we have the option to:

·        Pay
·        Replace (through a supplier of our choice)
·        Repair (through a repairer of our choice)
·        Any combination of the above.

Where we choose to replace or repair, we shall not be obliged to do so exactly or precisely but only as circumstance may reasonably allow. A contribution will be required by you where, as a result of repair or replacement, the condition and/or value of the insured property is improved.

In the event of a settlement by us for a total loss, the insured property or its salvage shall
become solely our property.

We also note that the jeweler sourced to design the jewelry item comes highly recommended and he is able to design the exact ring with the same metals and stones.

Please note based on the above, we are unable to pay out the full amount as we are proceeding with the option of replacing the item. Our stance as the Insurer is to put the client back in the same position that they were previously in and by replacing the lost item, we believe we are achieving this. 

Kind Regards
Market Conduct Department
PS
Peet S's update05 Nov 2021, 15:04
Reviewer Update
Good day,

With reference to the insured item. This is a designers ring. You cannot replace a designers ring by not using the original designer.

This is unacceptable.
New National Assurance Company Limited
New National Assurance Company Limited's reply10 Nov 2021, 15:19
Official
Good day, 

Please note that we are still reviewing this matter and will be in contact with you.

Regards

Market Conduct Department
PS
Peet S's update11 Nov 2021, 20:38
Reviewer Update
Good day,

Can you please provide me with an update on this situation.
PS
Peet S's update16 Nov 2021, 09:31
Reviewer Update
I heard nothing from you since?
New National Assurance Company Limited
New National Assurance Company Limited's reply23 Nov 2021, 12:06
Official
Good day, 

We confirm that you have referred this complaint to the Ombudsman for Short-term Insurance therefore we are now proceeding with closing the complaint on this forum.

All further communication will be dealt with via the Ombudsman.

Regards

Market Conduct Department